When sales, marketing, and finance operate in separate silos, the entire business suffers. Marketing celebrates lead volume while sales struggles with quality, and finance builds a budget based on numbers that feel disconnected from reality. This lack of alignment is a major roadblock to scalable growth. A reliable sales forecast acts as the ultimate source of truth, creating a shared language and a common goal for every department. It’s the connective tissue that ensures everyone is pulling in the same direction. Here, we’ll cover the data-driven sales forecasting methods that foster this crucial cross-functional alignment and build a unified revenue team.

Key Takeaways

  • Connect Your Forecast to Your Go-To-Market Strategy: Use your forecast as a central guide for major business decisions, including marketing budgets, hiring plans, and resource allocation, to ensure your entire organization is aligned on growth.
  • Build Your Forecast on a Foundation of Clean Data: An accurate forecast depends on reliable inputs. Establish clear standards for your CRM data and integrate insights from market trends and customer behavior to get a complete and trustworthy picture.
  • Adopt a Cycle of Continuous Improvement: Treat forecasting as a skill to be developed, not a task to be completed. Regularly measure your accuracy, refine your methods, and train your team to build a more predictable and reliable revenue engine over time.

What is Data-Driven Sales Forecasting (and Why Does It Matter)?

Let’s cut through the noise. At its core, sales forecasting is about using past sales data, current deals, and market trends to make an educated guess about future revenue. But when we add the "data-driven" element, it transforms from a guess into a strategic calculation. Instead of relying on gut feelings or overly optimistic projections, you’re using concrete evidence to guide your business decisions. This approach gives you a clear, objective view of your company’s performance, removing the guesswork that can lead to costly mistakes.

Think of it as your business’s GPS. A data-driven forecast provides crucial insights into your traction in the marketplace, the effectiveness of your marketing campaigns, and shifts in customer demand. It helps you answer critical questions: Are we on track to hit our targets? Do we need to hire more sales reps? Should we invest more in a specific marketing channel? By grounding your strategy in solid numbers, you can allocate resources more effectively, set realistic goals, and build a more predictable revenue engine. This isn't just about hitting a number; it's about building a scalable, resilient business. This is a foundational part of our purpose and process when we partner with tech companies.

How Data Shapes Modern Sales Forecasting

Not too long ago, sales forecasting lived in complex spreadsheets that were difficult to manage and prone to human error. Today, data has completely changed the game. With the help of AI and machine learning, modern sales forecasting tools can analyze past and current data to deliver automated, highly accurate insights. This technology can spot patterns and correlations that a person might miss, leading to more reliable predictions. The right tools don’t just predict future sales; they empower you to make smarter, data-backed decisions that keep your sales pipeline full and your team focused on the most promising opportunities.

Key Benefits for Tech Companies

For fast-moving tech companies, accurate forecasting isn't just a nice-to-have—it's a competitive advantage. It’s the secret weapon that helps you stay ahead of market trends, make smarter decisions, and drive sustainable revenue growth. When you have a clear picture of future sales, you can confidently plan your budget, manage inventory, and make strategic hiring decisions. More importantly, using sales analytics to identify high-quality leads can significantly improve your results; some studies show companies have increased lead conversions by over 30%. This data-centric approach creates a ripple effect, improving alignment across your sales, marketing, and product teams—a key outcome of our strategic offerings.

Key Sales Forecasting Methods to Know

Think of sales forecasting not as a crystal ball, but as a toolkit. Inside, you have several different tools, and the one you choose depends entirely on the job at hand. Are you launching a brand-new product with no sales history? Or are you operating in a stable market with years of data? Each scenario calls for a different approach. Understanding the primary forecasting methods is the first step toward building a reliable system that informs your entire Go-To-Market strategy.

The goal isn't to pick one method and stick with it forever. The most effective forecasting models often blend elements from different approaches. For instance, you might use a quantitative method to establish a baseline and then layer on qualitative insights from your sales team to adjust for a new competitor in the market. As your company grows and your data becomes more robust, you can graduate to more sophisticated techniques. Let’s walk through the four main methods you’ll encounter so you can identify which ones make the most sense for your business right now.

Qualitative Forecasting

When you don't have a mountain of historical data to lean on—maybe you're a startup or launching a new product line—qualitative forecasting is your best friend. This method relies on human expertise and judgment rather than algorithms. It involves gathering insights and opinions from the people on the front lines: your sales reps, senior leaders, and even industry experts. Techniques like the Delphi method or simple panel consensus are common here. It’s essentially a structured way of asking, “Based on what you’re seeing and hearing, where do you think we’ll land?” This approach adds a layer of real-world context that pure data sometimes misses.

Time Series Analysis

If your business has been operating for a while in a relatively stable market, time series analysis is a powerful quantitative method. It works by examining your past sales data to identify patterns, trends, and seasonality. The core assumption is that historical performance is a good predictor of future results. For example, if you consistently see a 20% sales spike every fourth quarter, this model will project a similar increase for the upcoming Q4. It’s a straightforward, data-driven approach that works well when you have several years of clean, consistent sales information to analyze for trends.

Causal Forecasting

Causal forecasting takes things a step further than time series analysis. Instead of just looking at past sales, it aims to understand the why behind the numbers. This method identifies the external and internal factors—the causes—that have a direct impact on your sales. These could include things like your marketing spend, competitor pricing changes, or even broader economic indicators. By building a model that connects these variables to sales outcomes, you can predict how future changes will affect your revenue. It’s a more complex approach, but it provides a much deeper understanding of the forces shaping your business.

AI-Powered Forecasting

Welcome to the next generation of forecasting. AI-powered methods use machine learning algorithms to analyze massive, complex datasets that go far beyond historical sales figures. These systems can process information from your CRM, marketing automation platform, and even external sources to identify subtle patterns and predict outcomes with incredible accuracy. An AI forecasting tool can flag at-risk deals, suggest next steps for reps, and run sophisticated “what-if” scenarios in seconds. As the AI learns from new data, its predictions become even smarter over time, giving your team a significant strategic advantage.

What Data Sources Fuel an Accurate Forecast?

A sales forecast is only as reliable as the data it’s built on. Relying on just one source, like your team’s gut feelings or last quarter's numbers, leaves you vulnerable to blind spots. The most accurate and resilient forecasts pull from a variety of sources, blending your internal performance with external market forces and customer insights. Think of it like building a complete puzzle—you need all the pieces to see the full picture.

Combining these different data streams gives you a multi-dimensional view of your business. Your internal data tells you what you’ve done, market data tells you what’s happening around you, and customer data helps you understand why it’s all happening. When you bring these together, you move from making educated guesses to making strategic, data-backed decisions. This approach is central to building a scalable revenue engine that can adapt to changing conditions and consistently hit its targets.

Internal Sales and CRM Data

Your own historical data is the foundation of any solid forecast. This is the information living inside your CRM and sales platforms, and it’s the most direct measure of your team’s performance and sales motion. It tells the story of what’s worked, what hasn’t, and what’s currently in motion. Start by analyzing your past sales data and your current pipeline to identify trends and establish a baseline for future performance.

Look at metrics like average deal size, sales cycle length, lead conversion rates, and win rates by rep or product. This internal data provides a clear, factual starting point. When your CRM data is clean and well-maintained, it becomes a powerful asset for predicting how your current pipeline will convert into closed-won revenue.

Market and Economic Data

While your internal data is critical, it doesn’t exist in a vacuum. External factors constantly influence your customers’ buying decisions and your overall market opportunity. Incorporating market and economic data helps you understand the broader context your business is operating in. This includes everything from industry-wide trends and competitor performance to macroeconomic indicators like inflation or changes in tech spending.

This information gives you insight into your company’s traction in the marketplace and helps you anticipate shifts in demand. For example, is a new competitor gaining market share? Is a new technology disrupting your industry? Staying informed on these external forces allows you to adjust your forecast to reflect real-world conditions, making it far more realistic and actionable for your Go-To-Market strategy.

Customer Behavior Data

Understanding how your customers interact with your product and brand provides a powerful layer of predictive insight. This data goes beyond simple transaction history to reveal the why behind their actions. By analyzing customer behavior, you can anticipate changes in buying patterns, identify churn risks, and spot opportunities for expansion revenue before they even show up in the pipeline.

Track metrics like product usage, feature adoption rates, support ticket volume, and engagement with marketing content. Modern tools, often powered by AI, can analyze this data to find patterns that signal a customer is ready to upgrade or, conversely, is at risk of leaving. These insights allow you to build a more nuanced forecast that accounts for the health and trajectory of your existing customer base.

How to Implement Data-Driven Forecasting

Shifting to a data-driven approach doesn’t happen overnight. It requires a solid foundation built on the right processes, clean data, and team-wide collaboration. Think of it as building a house—you can’t put up the walls without first pouring the concrete. The following steps will help you create a reliable and repeatable forecasting process that your entire organization can trust. By focusing on these core areas, you can move from guesswork to a strategic, data-informed system that truly supports your company's growth.

Build Your Forecasting Framework

A forecasting framework is your blueprint for predicting revenue. It’s a structured system that combines historical sales data, current pipeline activity, and market trends to create accurate projections. Instead of relying on a single method, a strong framework integrates multiple approaches to give you a more complete picture. This isn't about finding a magic formula, but about creating a consistent process. By using proven frameworks, you can ensure your team is always working with the same set of assumptions and methodologies. This consistency is what turns forecasting from a quarterly scramble into a strategic asset that informs decisions across the business.

Establish Data Quality Standards

Your sales forecast is only as good as the data it’s built on. If your CRM is filled with incomplete records, outdated contact information, or inconsistent deal stages, your projections will be unreliable. That’s why establishing clear standards for data quality is non-negotiable. Set clear rules for how your team enters and updates information, and perform regular checks to keep your data clean. Automating data collection and validation where possible can also help maintain accuracy. Think of it as preventative maintenance for your revenue engine—a little effort now saves you from major forecasting errors down the road.

Foster Cross-Functional Collaboration

Sales forecasting shouldn't happen in a vacuum. Your sales team has a direct view of the pipeline, but other departments hold key pieces of the puzzle. Marketing can provide insights on lead quality and campaign performance, finance can weigh in on budget assumptions, and product teams know what new features might impact sales cycles. Creating true cross-functional alignment ensures all these perspectives are considered, leading to a more holistic and accurate forecast. When everyone agrees on the data and the process, the forecast becomes a shared goal that the entire company can work toward together.

Common Challenges in Sales Forecasting (and How to Solve Them)

Even the most data-savvy teams hit roadblocks with sales forecasting. A few common hurdles can throw projections off course, but they are entirely solvable with the right strategy. Let's walk through the most frequent issues—from messy data to market surprises—and cover the practical steps you can take to address them.

Solving Data Quality and Gaps

Your forecast is only as reliable as the data it’s built on. When your CRM is cluttered with outdated contacts, duplicate entries, or incomplete deal information, your predictions will be skewed. This is the classic "garbage in, garbage out" problem, leading to misallocated resources and unrealistic targets.

To solve this, make data hygiene a non-negotiable priority. Start by establishing clear, simple rules for how your team enters and updates information in the CRM. Then, schedule regular data audits to clean up inconsistencies. A strong data governance framework ensures everyone is working with the same high-quality information, making your forecasts far more trustworthy.

Managing Market Volatility

Your business doesn't operate in a bubble, and neither should your forecast. Focusing only on internal sales data while ignoring external forces is a recipe for surprise. A competitor's new product launch, a shift in economic conditions, or new industry regulations can all have a major impact on your sales performance.

The key is to build a process for systematically tracking and incorporating these outside factors. Designate team members to monitor key industry trends, competitor activities, and relevant economic news. By treating this external information as a critical data source, you can create more resilient and realistic forecasts that account for the world your business actually operates in.

Overcoming Team Resistance to Change

Sometimes the biggest forecasting challenge is the human element. Sales reps can be naturally optimistic about their deals, while managers might be tempted to "sandbag" their numbers to ensure they hit their targets. These human biases, while understandable, can seriously distort your forecast's accuracy.

The solution lies in creating alignment and a shared sense of ownership. Get your sales, finance, and operations teams to agree on forecasting methodology and definitions. When everyone understands the process and trusts the numbers, you reduce bias and improve collaboration. This kind of cross-functional alignment is crucial for building a forecasting culture based on transparency and collective goals, not individual instincts.

The Right Tools and Tech for Sales Forecasting

Having the right methods is only half the battle; you need the right technology to execute them effectively. The right sales forecasting tools help you predict future sales, empower data-driven decisions, and keep your pipeline healthy. Think of your tech stack as the engine that powers your forecasting framework. It automates data collection, runs complex analyses, and presents insights in a way your team can actually use. Without solid technology, even the best forecasting model will struggle with manual errors, data silos, and slow, reactive analysis. This is especially true in fast-moving tech markets where conditions can change quickly.

Investing in the right tools isn't just about getting a more accurate number. It's about creating a single source of truth that aligns your sales, marketing, and finance teams. When everyone works from the same data and insights, you can make smarter strategic decisions, allocate resources more effectively, and build a predictable revenue engine. The goal is to move from gut-feel estimates to a system where you can confidently shape your sales strategy based on real-time data. A well-integrated tech stack removes the guesswork and replaces it with a clear, data-backed picture of where your business is headed, making it a true game-changer for scalable growth.

Our Recommended Platforms

Choosing the right platform starts with understanding your specific needs, but most tech companies will build their stack around a few core components. A powerful Customer Relationship Management (CRM) system is non-negotiable—it’s your central repository for all customer and deal data. Beyond the CRM, consider dedicated business intelligence (BI) or sales analytics platforms that specialize in forecasting. These tools often have more advanced modeling capabilities and can pull data from multiple sources. When evaluating options, look for platforms that are user-friendly, customizable to your sales process, and scalable enough to grow with you. The key is to find a tool that doesn't just store data but helps you leverage it effectively for accurate predictions.

Essential CRM Integrations

Your CRM is the heart of your sales data, but it shouldn't be an island. To get a complete picture for forecasting, you need to integrate it with the other tools in your ecosystem. Think about connecting your marketing automation platform to track lead sources and campaign influence, your customer support software to understand customer health and churn risk, and your financial software for a clear view of revenue. These integrations break down data silos and ensure your forecast is based on a holistic view of the customer journey. Optimizing these connections is a core part of building a robust revenue operations function that supports predictable growth.

AI Forecasting Platforms

Artificial intelligence is transforming sales forecasting from a reactive exercise into a proactive one. AI-driven platforms use machine learning algorithms to analyze vast amounts of historical and real-time data, identifying complex patterns that a human analyst might miss. These tools can automatically adjust for seasonality, market trends, and individual rep performance to deliver highly accurate predictions. More importantly, they can provide automated insights, flagging at-risk deals or highlighting opportunities with a high probability of closing. By incorporating an AI-driven forecasting tool, you equip your team with the intelligence to focus their efforts where they’ll have the greatest impact.

Analytics and Visualization Tools

Raw data and complex spreadsheets can be overwhelming and difficult to interpret. That’s where analytics and visualization tools come in. Platforms like Tableau, Power BI, or even the built-in dashboards in modern CRMs turn your forecasting data into intuitive charts, graphs, and reports. Visualizing your pipeline, conversion rates, and forecast accuracy helps your entire team understand performance at a glance. This clarity is crucial for holding productive forecast review meetings and making informed decisions. Effective data visualization makes your forecast accessible and actionable, ensuring the insights you generate actually drive behavior and strategy across the organization.

How to Measure Your Forecasting Accuracy

Creating a sales forecast is just the first step. The real value comes from consistently measuring its accuracy and using those insights to refine your process. A forecast isn't a "set it and forget it" document; it's a living tool that should get smarter over time. By tracking how your predictions stack up against actual results, you can identify weak spots in your sales process, coach your team more effectively, and build a more predictable revenue engine.

Good forecasts help you plan for customer demand, make smarter investments, and spot potential issues before they become major problems. But you can only achieve that if you have a clear system for evaluating your performance. Let's walk through the key components of measuring your forecasting accuracy.

KPIs to Track

To understand if your forecast is on track, you need to monitor the right key performance indicators (KPIs). These metrics give you a clear, quantitative view of your sales health and forecasting skill. Start by tracking Forecast Accuracy itself—the percentage difference between your predicted revenue and your actual revenue. Also, keep an eye on Sales Cycle Length to see if deals are closing faster or slower than anticipated. Finally, monitor Quota Attainment to ensure your team's goals are both ambitious and realistic. These KPIs provide the data you need to make informed adjustments and align your sales activities with your company's strategic purpose and process.

Analyzing Win Rates and Conversions

Numbers tell part of the story, but win rates and conversion metrics add crucial context. Analyzing why you win or lose deals helps you understand the "who" and "why" behind your forecast. By examining the characteristics of your closed-won opportunities, you can find out who your best customers are and double down on what works. Similarly, tracking conversion rates between sales stages reveals where deals are stalling. If opportunities are consistently getting stuck in the proposal stage, for example, you know there’s a friction point that’s likely throwing off your forecast’s timing and value.

Setting Accuracy Benchmarks

It’s important to have a goal to aim for. If your forecasts feel like a shot in the dark, you’re not alone. Research shows that fewer than half of sales leaders can predict sales within 10% accuracy. The goal isn't perfection overnight, but steady improvement. Start by establishing a baseline for your current forecast accuracy. From there, set a realistic benchmark for improvement—perhaps aiming to get within a 15% variance each quarter. As you refine your data inputs and sales process, you can tighten that benchmark. This creates a clear target and turns forecasting into a skill your team can actively develop and significantly improve over time.

Best Practices for Maintaining Forecast Quality

A sales forecast isn't a "set it and forget it" document. It's a living tool that needs consistent attention to stay sharp and reliable. Think of it like a high-performance engine; it requires regular maintenance to keep running smoothly and delivering the results you need. Without it, even the most sophisticated forecasting model will start to lose its accuracy.

Maintaining forecast quality comes down to three core habits: keeping your data clean, ensuring your team is on the same page, and using technology to handle the heavy lifting. By building these practices into your sales operations, you create a feedback loop that continuously refines your predictions. This not only leads to more accurate forecasts but also builds confidence across the organization, from the sales floor to the C-suite. It’s a foundational part of building a scalable, data-driven culture that can adapt to whatever the market throws its way.

Conduct Regular Data Audits

Your forecast is only as good as the data it’s built on. That’s why regular data audits are non-negotiable. Think of it as a routine health check for your CRM. Set clear, simple rules for how your team enters information and schedule time—monthly or quarterly—to review your data for accuracy and completeness. Inaccurate or messy data will always lead to a flawed forecast.

A consistent audit process helps you spot issues early, like duplicate records, incomplete fields, or outdated opportunity stages. Correcting these problems ensures your historical data is a reliable foundation for future predictions. This commitment to data integrity is a key part of our proven frameworks, as it ensures every strategic decision is based on a clear and accurate picture of reality.

Standardize Team Training

For your team to contribute to an accurate forecast, they need to understand the "why" behind the data. Standardized training ensures everyone is using the CRM the same way and understands how their daily entries impact the bigger picture. Use simple visuals and dashboards to make the data easy to digest.

More importantly, show your reps how accurate data helps them close more deals and hit their targets. When you can connect clean data directly to their personal success, you get buy-in instead of resistance. Celebrate wins that came from data-driven insights and make it a regular topic in coaching sessions. This approach turns data entry from a chore into a strategic part of the sales process, something we emphasize in our sales training and coaching.

Automate Data Collection

Manual data entry is not only time-consuming, but it’s also a major source of human error. The more you can automate data collection, the cleaner your data will be and the more time your team can spend actually selling. Modern sales tools can automatically log calls, emails, and meeting notes directly into your CRM.

Leveraging AI and machine learning can take this a step further. These tools can analyze past and current data to provide automated insights, flagging at-risk deals or identifying promising opportunities without anyone having to lift a finger. Implementing this kind of technology is a core component of revenue operations optimization, as it frees up your team to focus on high-value activities while ensuring your forecast is built on a foundation of complete, accurate data.

Integrate Forecasting into Your Go-To-Market Strategy

A sales forecast is much more than a report for your leadership team—it's a critical component of your entire go-to-market (GTM) strategy. When you treat forecasting as an isolated sales activity, you miss the opportunity to align your entire organization around a unified plan for growth. A strong, data-driven forecast should inform every aspect of your GTM motion, from marketing campaign budgets and hiring plans to product development priorities and territory assignments. It provides the connective tissue that ensures every department is working from the same set of assumptions and toward the same revenue objectives.

Integrating forecasting into your GTM strategy transforms it from a reactive, backward-looking report into a proactive, forward-looking guide. It helps you allocate resources effectively, identify potential risks before they become major problems, and capitalize on emerging opportunities with confidence. This level of cross-functional alignment is what separates high-growth tech companies from the rest. By making the forecast a central piece of your strategic planning process, you empower every team—from sales and marketing to product and finance—to make smarter, more coordinated decisions that drive sustainable revenue.

Align Forecasts with Revenue Goals

Your forecast is the bridge between your high-level revenue goals and the day-to-day activities of your sales team. It breaks down that ambitious annual target into concrete, achievable milestones for each quarter, month, and week. This process ensures your goals are grounded in reality, based on historical data, pipeline health, and market conditions. When your forecast is directly tied to revenue targets, it becomes a powerful tool for accountability and performance management.

Sales teams can see exactly what they need to close to stay on track, and leaders can use the data to make well-informed decisions about where to invest more resources or provide additional coaching. By using forecasting to predict future sales, you create a clear path to your revenue goals and empower your team with the insights needed to walk it.

Support Strategic Planning

A reliable forecast offers a clear view of your company’s position in the market. It’s not just about predicting sales; it’s about understanding the story the data tells. Are you gaining momentum in a key segment? Is a new marketing channel delivering higher-quality leads? Is demand shifting in response to economic changes? These are the strategic questions a good forecast helps you answer.

This data provides critical insights into market traction and the effectiveness of your current strategies. You can use this information to make pivotal decisions, like whether to enter a new market, adjust your pricing model, or reallocate your marketing budget. Your forecast acts as a reality check for your strategic plan, ensuring your ambitions are supported by real-world data.

Use Scenario Modeling and Planning

The market is never static, and your GTM strategy shouldn't be either. Integrating forecasting allows you to move beyond a single, static prediction and embrace scenario modeling. By creating best-case, likely, and worst-case scenarios, you can prepare your business for a range of potential outcomes. What happens if a major deal slips into the next quarter? What if a new marketing campaign outperforms expectations? Scenario planning helps you build contingency plans for these possibilities.

Modern tools, especially those with AI-driven insights, make this process more accessible than ever. They can analyze vast datasets to identify trends and model different futures, helping you stay ahead of market shifts. This proactive approach builds resilience and agility directly into your GTM strategy, ensuring you’re ready to adapt no matter what comes your way.

Related Articles

Frequently Asked Questions

My company is new and doesn't have much historical data. Can we still create an accurate forecast? Absolutely. This is a common situation for startups and companies launching new products. In this case, you’ll lean more on qualitative forecasting methods. This approach relies on the expertise of your team rather than historical numbers. You can gather insights from your sales reps on the front lines, get input from senior leadership, and even consult with industry experts to build a well-rounded projection. It’s about structuring those expert opinions into a forecast that reflects the real-world conversations and market feedback you’re getting right now.

How do I get my sales team to take data quality seriously? The key is to connect clean data directly to their success. Instead of framing it as an administrative chore, show them how an accurate CRM helps them close more deals. When data is reliable, you can better identify which leads are most promising, understand the sales activities that actually lead to wins, and create more effective coaching plans. Make data hygiene a shared responsibility and celebrate the wins that come from data-driven insights. When your team sees that good data helps them hit their own targets, they become invested in the process.

Which forecasting method is the right one for my business? There isn't a single "best" method; the right approach depends on your company's stage, market stability, and data maturity. A new company might start with a qualitative forecast, while a business with years of consistent sales history could use time series analysis. The most effective strategy often blends different methods. You might use historical data to set a baseline, then layer on qualitative insights from your team to account for a new competitor or product launch. The goal is to choose the tools that give you the clearest picture right now and be ready to evolve your methods as your business grows.

How often should we be reviewing and updating our sales forecast? A sales forecast shouldn't be a static document you create once a quarter and file away. Think of it as a living tool that guides your weekly and monthly decisions. Many high-performing teams conduct weekly pipeline reviews to check progress against the forecast and make small adjustments. A more formal, in-depth re-forecasting process should happen at least monthly. This regular cadence ensures your forecast remains relevant and allows you to react quickly to changes in your pipeline or the market.

What's a realistic goal for forecast accuracy when we're just starting out? Perfection isn't the goal, especially when you're first implementing a data-driven process. Many sales leaders struggle to forecast within a 10% variance of actual results. A realistic starting point is to aim for an accuracy rate of 80-85%. The most important thing is to track your accuracy consistently and focus on steady improvement. By analyzing where your predictions missed the mark each quarter, you can refine your data, adjust your assumptions, and make your forecast more reliable over time.